Position statement from the IHC Scientific Committee
Sep 19, 2023 | News
On 12 September, at a meeting of the IHC’s Scientific Committee, it was unanimously decided to send a letter to the publisher Routledge expressing its position on the withdrawal of the chapter “The Walls Spoke When No One Else Would. Autoethnographic notes on sexual-power gatekeeping within avant-garde academia”, from the book Sexual Misconduct in Academia, edited by Erin Pritchard and Delyth Edwards (2023).
Below is the letter.
Lisbon, 12 September 2023
Dear Routledge Editors,
The news that Routledge has decided to withdraw the chapter written by Lieselotte Viaene, Catarina Laranjeiro and Myie Nadia Tom “The Walls Spoke When No One Else Would. Autoethnographic notes on sexual-power gatekeeping within avant-garde academia”, from the book Sexual Misconduct in Academia, edited by Erin Pritchard and Delyth Edwards (2023), has shocked and surprised us.
The chapter analyzes the complexities of structural sexual harassment and power abuses in academia, suggesting that such misconducts are by no means isolated and constitute a widespread problem. Such publication enabled and encouraged extensive public debates on these issues within and outside academia. By removing the chapter, Routledge is hindering the discussion of sexual harassment and power abuses in academia and is effectively partaking in its silencing mechanisms.
The chapter was published in a book subjected to Taylor and Francis’ Book Publishing Process, which includes an internal editorial assessment by a Routledge Editor, a peer review, and, finally, a Routledge editorial board meeting, which results in a “final decision on approving the book for publication”, according to the Publishing Process statement. Routledge establishes the “basic steps to our publishing process for transforming an idea to an authoritative book for academic study or professional development.” It is deeply problematic that an independent academic publisher disregards the position and protests of the editors of the book and of the authors of the chapter as well as its own Publishing Process. Routledge’s retraction of the chapter, which was done without clarification of the proceedings and reasons behind it, lacks the necessary transparency and raises great concern regarding the future of academic and scientific freedom.
By censoring this chapter, Routledge is not only bypassing and disrespecting academic procedures, but also undermining the confidence of Routledge readers and authors, jeopardizing the independence of knowledge. We thus call for the reversal of this act of censorship and for the re-inclusion of the chapter in the original publication.
The Scientific Committee of the IHC
(Institute of Contemporary History, NOVA University Lisbon and University of Évora)
News
-
The IHC Summer School will return to the University of Évora for its third edition
-
The historian of science will be the fourth IHC Visiting Scholar
-
Quintino Lopes visited the building that housed the former Phonetics Laboratory of the Federal University of Bahia
-
The PhD candidate has been selected for the 2024 edition of TheMuseumsLab
-
António Cândido Franco's biography of Luiz Pacheco was the winner
-
Panel of the Franco-German Fund on the Provenance of Cultural Objects from sub-Saharan Africa.
-
Catarina Laranjeiro and Daniel Barroca opened the exhibition at Fidelidade Arte
-
Daniel Alves is the scientific curator of the exhibition "Lisbon in revolution, 1383-1974"
-
Hundreds of specialists in historiography and history theory will be in Lisbon
-
Joana Dias Pereira and Gil Gonçalves were the scientific commissioners
-
Victor Pereira was one of the curators of the exhibition "Regards français sur la Révolution des œillets"
-
Luís Trindade, Zélia Pereira and José Neves had three new projects funded by the FCT
-
Paulo Catrica is the curator of the exhibition "A Revolução em Marcha".
-
The book on the 170 years of the graphic association movement has been launched.
-
The exhibition PPP Porosità, Poética e Política, by Paulo Catrica, opened in Porto.
-
Rui Lopes has been awarded a Remarque Visiting Fellowship at New York University.
-
Jorge Custódio received the Gold Medal of the Municipality of Santarém
-
The IHC and the Padrão dos Descobrimentos / EGEAC have opened the competition for the third edition of the...
-
Ana Cristina Martins has been appointed Corresponding Academician and the inauguration will take place on 20 March.
-
From Famalicão to the World: 25 April 1974 - The Meaning of a Historic Date in Vila Nova de...
Search
Opportunities
Marie Skłodowska-Curie Postdoctoral Fellowships
Deadline (IHC): 23 June 2024
News
Third IHC Summer School in Évora
Jul 15, 2024
The IHC Summer School will return to the University of Évora for its third edition
Lavinia Maddaluno is IHC’s 2024 Visiting Scholar
Jul 11, 2024
The historian of science will be the fourth IHC Visiting Scholar
Quintino Lopes visits Salvador, Bahia
Jul 9, 2024
Quintino Lopes visited the building that housed the former Phonetics Laboratory of the Federal University of Bahia